Brethren by Nature: New England Indians, Colonists, and the Origins of American Slavery

Brethren by NatureIn Brethren by Nature, Margaret Ellen Newell reveals a little-known aspect of American history: English colonists in New England enslaved thousands of Indians. Massachusetts became the first English colony to legalize slavery in 1641, and the colonists’ desire for slaves shaped the major New England Indian wars, including the Pequot War of 1637, King Philip’s War of 1675–76, and the northeastern Wabanaki conflicts of 1676–1749. When the wartime conquest of Indians ceased, New Englanders turned to the courts to get control of their labor, or imported Indians from Florida and the Carolinas, or simply claimed free Indians as slaves.


Drawing on letters, diaries, newspapers, and court records, Newell recovers the slaves’ own stories and shows how they influenced New England society in crucial ways. Indians lived in English homes, raised English children, and manned colonial armies, farms, and fleets, exposing their captors to Native religion, foods, and technology. Some achieved freedom and power in this new colonial culture, but others experienced violence, surveillance, and family separations.


Newell also explains how slavery linked the fate of Africans and Indians. The trade in Indian captives connected New England to Caribbean and Atlantic slave economies. Indians labored on sugar plantations in Jamaica, tended fields in the Azores, and rowed English naval galleys in Tangier. Indian slaves outnumbered Africans within New England before 1700, but the balance soon shifted. Fearful of the growing African population, local governments stripped Indian and African servants and slaves of legal rights and personal freedoms. Nevertheless, because Indians remained a significant part of the slave population, the New England colonies did not adopt all of the rigid racial laws typical of slave societies in Virginia and Barbados. Newell finds that second- and third-generation Indian slaves fought their enslavement and claimed citizenship in cases that had implications for all enslaved peoples in eighteenth-century America.


You can purchase the book at

Review of the book by Greenberry Griffith

I consider myself something of an American history buff, but this book made me realize I knew next to nothing about the history of colonial New England in the 150 years between the arrival of the Mayflower and the Revolution.

Newell’s extremely thorough, well-researched book charts the complicated, evolving relationship between colonial Europeans and Native Americans during that period, and it’s really informative and eye-opening.

Using surviving period court records, newspaper accounts, and personal journals of prominent citizens, Newell pieces together a fascinating, nuanced story of shifting alliances and tensions – not only between the colonies and Native tribes, but also between the tribes themselves – that lead to game-changing conflicts like the Pequot War. She then explains how these events led to colonial justification and eventual codifcation of Indian slavery, which laid the legal foundations for African slavery on this continent.

This is definitely an overlooked chapter of American history. Hats off to Newell for shining a new light on this period, and for doing so in a way that’s both interesting and readable (even for non-academic types like me).

Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply